Safety Rating: Acceptable
| Product | Brand | Score |
|---|---|---|
| Kirkland Signature Pate Cat Food Variety Pack 45-count | Kirkland Signature | 65/100 — Good |
| cat food | Felix | 49/100 — Poor |
| Premium Cat Food Turkey & Giblets Entree | Heart to tail | 46/100 — Poor |
| Fancy Feast Classic Pate Chicken Feast Wet Cat Food 3 oz (24-pack) | Fancy Feast | 46/100 — Poor |
| Fancy Feast Kitten Tender Chicken Feast | Purina | 46/100 — Poor |
| Friskies - Paté - Sea Captain's Choice | Friskies | 44/100 — Poor |
| Turkey & giblets dinner pate | Friskies | 44/100 — Poor |
| Chicken dinner pate | Friskies | 44/100 — Poor |
| Ocean whitefish & tuna dinner pate | Friskies | 44/100 — Poor |
| Purina fish and shrimp pate cat food | Fancy Feast | 42/100 — Poor |
| Seafood Classic Pate Collection | Fancy Feast | 42/100 — Poor |
| Fancy Feast Beef Feast In Gravy Grilled | Fancy Feast | 42/100 — Poor |
| Fancy Feast Kitten Tender Turkey Recipe | Purina | 40/100 — Poor |
| Tuna Cat Treats - 4 ct | Friskies | 39/100 — Poor |
| Chicken with Garden Veggies Wet Cat Food | Friskies | 39/100 — Poor |